North Carolina Congressman Madison Cawthorn, a 26-year-old scandal-ridden Republican, became a rare exception when he lost his primary race on Tuesday. Will Democrats and Big Tech ever apologize? As soon as I realized that she didnt want to I think she pulled back a little bit the date was over and we continued to sit around the fire for quite a while. See our favorite looks from outside the shows. "If you remember back when Bill Clinton ran for president, they had the slogan, 'It's the economy, stupid.' In some ways, Cooper says, Edwards success is precisely because hes not the star-power candidate.. Jasmine Beach-Ferrara was the first person to share her plans unseat the antigay Republican lawmaker in 2022 when she announced her candidacy last March, less than two months after he was sworn into office. Cawthorn would take young women to secluded areas, lock the doors, and proceed to make unwanted sexual advances, the letter read. Even Paul Mescal Is Intimidated by Zendaya. Last year, retired Air Force Colonel Davis ran a tough campaign against Cawthorn, calling him out on social media as an habitual liar and a racist. His MO was to take vulnerable women out on these rides with him in the car, and to make advances, Caitlin Coulter, one of Cawthorns former college classmates, told CNN. Edwards, a well-established figure in local and statewide politics, was the natural choice to replace him. Cawthorn attacks anyway", "The 'Dark MAGA' movement dreams of a vengeful Trump destroying his enemies, and is using 'meme warfare' to amplify its threatening vision, say experts", "Cawthorn Challenge Raises the Question: Who Is an 'Insurrectionist'? He had also been reportedly cited for having a 9mm handgun in his luggage at Charlotte Douglas International Airport in late April. When Cawthorn was campaigning for congress, over 150 Patrick Henry alums shared a letter opposing his candidacy and said that Cawthorns time at PHC was marked by gross misconduct towards our female peers, public misrepresentation of his past, disorderly conduct that was against the schools student honor code, and self-admitted academic failings., I personally experienced Cawthorns predatory behavior and sexual harassment, which is why I signed this letter with other alum. Bruce O'Connell, owner of the Pisgah Inn, becomes the latest Republican to challenge Rep. Madison Cawthorn. Cawthorn, the youngest member of Congress at 26 and an outspoken conservative, is in the political fight of his life. The articles from Inside Politics With Steve Harrison appear first in his weekly newsletter, which takes a deeper look at local politics, including the latest news on the Charlotte City Council, what's happening with Mecklenburg County's Board of Commissioners, the North Carolina General Assembly and much more. One example was his response to an August 2021 flood that killed several people, injured others, and left thousands of people in Western North Carolina without power. Im running because the 14-month experiment here in District 11 has concluded, and its time to send someone to Washington, D.C., to represent the people of the mountains who has a deep history of accomplishment in life and in business and in serving the people of the district, Edwards told the Washington Examiner in an interview. Cawthorn, who quickly aligned himself with Trump, basked in the attention and sought to leverage his newfound fame to become a Republican power player who could bully party leaders and influence. Cawthorns talk of bloodshed may cost him voters like Jackson. North Carolina Congressman Madison Cawthorn, a 26-year-old scandal-ridden Republican, became a rare exception when he lost his primary race on Tuesday. In answer to Free Speech for People, lawyers argued that an 1872 amnesty law for former Confederates did not only apply retroactively. Cawthorn replaced outgoing Representative Mark Meadows who left to become President Trump's chief of staff in 2020. Ultimately, experts say, it wasnt just the district flip-flopping, misdemeanors, or lewd acts caught on camera that cost Cawthorn his seat. Praveen Fernandes, vice-president of the Constitutional Accountability Center, which filed an amicus brief, said: Although Representative Cawthorn just lost his partys nomination for his seat in Congress, todays ruling remains an incredibly important one. Made me less intelligent. [124] One woman said Cawthorn called her "just a little blonde, slutty American girl" when she rejected his sexual advances. Cawthorn, 26, became the youngest member of Congress after his November 2020 election, and has become a social media favorite of Trump supporters. Tillis also called on the House Ethics Committee to investigate Cawthorn over his alleged involvement in insider trading connected to his Lets Go Brandon cryptocurrency, The Hill reported. [135] Cawthorn had court dates in Polk and Cleveland counties in June 2022 for speeding and driving with a revoked license. Then, in February, Cawthorn reneged on his choice and opted to run again in his current district after all, and had to face Edwards. [52] Edwards had been supported by Senator Thom Tillis and most of the North Carolina General Assembly. Cawthorn lost a primary this month and will not return when the new Congress convenes in January. With his combative personality and telegenic good looks, the then-24-year-old Cawthorn became a favorite of grassroots conservatives nationally in 2020, soon after defeating the preferred candidate of the GOP establishment, and former President Donald Trump, in an open primary in North Carolinas 11th District. Katrina Krulikas, a North Carolina resident who was part of the same home-schooling network as Cawthorn, was one of the first women to come forward with allegations against the congressman. Its not easy to hop on a train and get across town, says Cooper. So did U.S. Sen. Thom Tillis (R-N.C.). That has been a real black eye on his constituency service operation., And despite his stated staffing priorities, Cawthorn also lacked a strong communications strategy. Cawthorns loss did not come as a surprise to the states political experts and GOP operatives. The first-term congressman fell short despite a late appeal from Trump, who encouraged voters to look past the young lawmakers string of missteps. Edwards is one of seven Republicans running against Cawthorn. Cawthorn's response letter implied support by former Patrick Henry College President Michael Farris; Farris disavowed the support letter and asked that he not be associated with it. [95] Harp was Cawthorn's campaign manager in 2020, becoming chief of staff in 2021.[96]. One of Rep. Madison Cawthorn's Democratic challengers (who happens to be gay) just released a new attack ad against him and the Claws. Cawthorn's non-stop stream of scandals including accusing his Capitol Hill colleagues of attending orgies and using cocaine, repeatedly running afoul of the law, and rubbing his naked genitals on his cousin's head in a leaked video ultimately made him a liability in the eyes of the GOP establishment. Caption: Several potential candidates interested in running against Cawthorn for NC's 11th district. Its a basic western North Carolina seat that is just conservative. Do you want a grown-up who has been successful in business and delivered on the legislation for the district? Cawthorn is still favored to win his May 17 primary, Republican insiders in North Carolina said. On Tuesday, he beat Donald Trump' s . But seven Democrats are running. And she wants to delay her 11-year prison sentence. He issued a call to mothers, who he said are the "most vicious" conservatives: "If you are raising a young man, please raise them to be a monster". Since being elected into office, the police have twice cited the Republican. In one of the most high-profile races in the country, Cawthorn conceded defeat to Chuck Edwards, a North Carolina Republican State senator and small businessman, late Tuesday night. Both Sides of a Breakup: She Didnt Tell Her Family She Was Dating a Woman, At Bottega Veneta, Characters You May Know. As of Wednesday morning, Cawthorn trailed Edwards by at least 1.5%, or 1,319 votes. ought not know what the odds against further aid is, and ought not know how much support there may or may not be in the world for helping . [121], Cawthorn said that he trained in wheelchair racing for the 2020 Summer Paralympics, but never competed at a qualifying level and was not involved in a team. McCarthy said he had told Cawthorn that "He's lost my trust. She says he pressured her to sit in his lap, and then took things further. Prior to joining WFAE, Steve worked at the Charlotte Observer, where he started on the business desk, then covered politics extensively as the Observers lead city government reporter. Now, those lawmakers can breathe a sigh of relief. Some in His District Have, Too", "Cawthorn's orgies-and-drugs comment stirs trouble within Freedom Caucus", "Rep. Madison Cawthorn admits lying about cocaine and orgies after tongue-lashing from GOP leaders", "Group seeks ethics investigation into Madison Cawthorn", "Cawthorn hit with new ethics complaint filed by rival PAC", "Pressure Mounts on Cawthorn as Scandals Pile Up", "Madison Cawthorn May Have a New Ethics Violation to Handle", "The fall and rise and fall of Madison Cawthorn", "Madison Cawthorn vacates offices before end of term; constituents' calls go unanswered", "Congressman-elect begins work early after constituents ignored by current Congressman", "Abortion, guns and freedom: How Madison Cawthorn's platform won WNC voters", "Who is Madison Cawthorn? [33][37] In response, Cawthorn denied being a white supremacist, calling the allegations ridiculous, and said he "completely and wholeheartedly denounce[s] any kind of white nationalism, any kind of Nazism". Rep. Madison Cawthorn is returning to his home district to run for reelection after a court-ordered redrawing of North Carolina's congressional map. An effort by North Carolina voters to block Rep. Madison Cawthorn (R-N.C.) from running for reelection because he's an "insurrectionist" has failed, after a federal judge granted Cawthorn's. The vehicle crashed into a concrete barrier while Cawthorn's feet were on the dashboard. Alyssa Farah Griffin, for whom Cawthorn once interned, condemned his comments as based on ignorance and spreading Russian propaganda. The next, he's trumpeting dangerous conspiracies to right-wing crowds and commentators. [31][46] He is also the first member of Congress born in the 1990s. [97] He subsequently purchased a $1.1 million dollar home in Florida. He won his district with a campaign that advanced falsehoods about the 2020 election, spread lies about his own personal history, and openly espoused hateful, racist rhetoric. Experts describe Edwards as a modest, religious conservative who has a reputation for staying out of the spotlight which may have made him more appealing to North Carolina voters growing irritated by Cawthorns tendency to grab headlines. All rights reserved. The question is whether Cawthorns $1.6 million (in fundraising) has scared him off, he said. [26], In the March 2020 Republican primary for North Carolina's 11th congressional district, Cawthorn finished second behind Lynda Bennett, who had been endorsed both by President Donald Trump and Meadows, who had become White House Chief of Staff. Born during Black History Month, with a name to match!. If the two top candidates did not meet the 30% threshold, they would face a runoff election in July. [81], At an August 2021 Republican Party event in Macon County, Cawthorn said: "if our election systems continue to be rigged and continue to be stolen, then it's going to lead to one placeand it's bloodshed." [122][123], In August 2020, during Cawthorn's campaign for Congress, several women accused him of sexually aggressive behavior, sexual misconduct, and sexual assault. By submitting your email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Notice and to receive email correspondence from us. "The problems in D.C. are too severe to treat as a training camp.". "[39][40] The sentence on the website was later modified to claim Fiedler is "an unapologetic defender of left-wing identity politics". [11] He had said he intended to use his position to be a messenger rather than a legislator, writing to his colleagues, "I have built my staff around comms rather than legislation. [33][36] Some Jewish residents of his congressional district expressed concern about the incident, including Esther Manheimer, mayor of Asheville, the district's largest city. Hailing a major victory, Free Speech For People, the group which brought the case, said: This ruling cements the growing judicial consensus that the 1872 Amnesty Act does not shield the insurrectionists of 6 January 2021 including Donald Trump from the consequences of their actions.. Trump-backed nominees lost in Georgia, but can Republicans escape the specter of Maga? On Tuesday, that could cost him his job. A political group supporting Senator Thom Tillis, Republican of North Carolina, has been pouring money into an ad campaign accusing Mr. Cawthorn of being a fame-seeking liar. [27][30] His victory has been called an upset. #RejectCawthorn #StandForConsent pic.twitter.com/Xi08Ml6TvI, During his brief time at the college, the letter continues, Cawthorn established a reputation for predatory behavior. [37], Cawthorn spoke on the third day of the 2020 Republican National Convention. [18][124][125][126], Katrina Krulikas described an incident when she was 17 and Cawthorn was 19 in which he pressured her to sit on his lap and attempted to kiss her forcibly twice, which she resisted. A Running List of the Allegations Against GOP seditionist Rep Madison Cawthorn. [33][36] He had referred to Hitler as "the Fhrer", Hitler's official title, and also called Hitler "a supreme evil". On November 16, 2022, Joel Burgess of the Asheville Citizen-Times wrote Cawthorn had vacated and shut down his offices two months before the end of his term. [89] McCarthy later told reporters that Cawthorn had admitted his claims were exaggerated or untrue: "He changes what he tells and that's not becoming of a congressman. Rep. Madison Cawthorn and his wife of 8 months, Cristina Cawthorn, are divorcing. [43][44][45], Cawthorn is the youngest Republican and one of the youngest members ever elected to the House of Representatives. He took office on January 3, 2021. But now his ability to run for reelection in the fall is being . NC District 11 can do better. The judge argued the North Carolina Elections Board cannot make judgements on Cawthorns alleged role in the January 6 riot. Then my doctor prescribed me an injectable weight-loss drug that upended everything. Cawthorn emerged as a right-wing star during his 2020 campaign, sticking close to Trump even as he fanned the flames of conspiracy theories about winning the election against now-President Joe Biden. It was too little too late. [27][28] But Bennett did not receive the required 30% of the vote to avoid a runoff and Cawthorn won the June runoff overwhelmingly. The race consisted of challengers Rod Honeycutt, Michele Woodhouse, Matthew Burril, Wendy Nevarez, Bruce O'Connell and Kristie Sluder. Cawthorn got off on the wrong track with many voters this cycle by initially choosing to run in a neighboring district before he decided to seek re-election in the 11th District, instead. Cawthorn, 26, lost despite an eleventh-hour appeal from Trump, who encouraged voters to look past his run-ins with the law, claims that fellow lawmakers use cocaine and engage in orgies, and images of him wearing lingerie and gyrating naked atop another man in bed. [74], On January 20, the day of Joe Biden's inauguration, Cawthorn was one of 17 newly elected House Republicans to sign a letter congratulating him and expressing hope of bipartisan cooperation. [5], In April 2022, Senator Thom Tillis called for an investigation into Cawthorn for possible violations of the STOCK Act, stating that Cawthorn's purchase of an anti-Biden "Let's Go Brandon" cryptocurrency without disclosure may have violated insider trading rules for members of Congress. On Friday, he . "[73] He later attempted to blame the riots on a "Democratic machine" of "agitators strategically placed inside of this group", amid intensifying calls for his resignation for his part in stoking the riots. Ive actually achieved or passed legislation to improve election integrity., No one else in this race can say theyve done those things. Some, like credible allegations of serial sexual misconduct and multiple weapon violations, are potentially criminal.Others, like misleading people about military service and training for the Paralympics, reveal a tenuous relationship with the truth.Still more, like telling a disability rights activist to "chill the . The leaders of the North Carolina state Senate and. [94], In May 2022, The Daily Beast reported that Blake Harp, Cawthorn's chief of staff, who was paid $131,278 in that position in 2021, also received $73,237 in that year from Cawthorn's campaign, despite House ethics rules that limit senior staff to earning $29,595 in outside income each year. WASHINGTON Buckling under the weight of scandal, Rep. Madison Cawthorn, R-N.C. a favorite of former President Donald Trump lost his re-nomination bid in western North Carolinas 11th District on Tuesday, NBC News projected. A 24-year-old real estate investment CEO and motivational speaker is the winner of a North Carolina House GOP primary, The Associated Press projects. The Week is part of Future plc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. [80] In July 2021, another ethics complaint was filed against Cawthorn by an aide to Representative David McKinley after Cawthorn first scolded a McKinley aide and later got into a shouting match with McKinley over being listed as a co-sponsor of McKinley's bill. Shawn Mendes Has Resumed His Paparazzi Strolls. North Carolina Republican House candidate Michele Woodhouse, who's running against Cawthorn after supporting him in 2020, told CNN on Friday that people in the district were "really upset" about . According to her account, they sat around a bonfire, and soon, Cawthorn started talking about sex, which made Krulikas uncomfortable. I realized she didnt want to pursue a romantic relationship and so I dont think I talked to her very much after that.. With 19 months to go before the general election, Rep. Madison Cawthorn, R-Henderson, is facing a Republican opponent as well as five Democrats who will compete in their own primary to face. The second hurdle for Cawthorn is the Republican primary in March. On his campaign website, Honeycutt called out Cawthorn: I will not watch from the sidelines as inexperienced, self-promoting characters seek to further careers while the hard-working men and women of WNC suffer the consequences. They include LGBTQ activist and Buncombe County Commissioner Jasmine Beach-Ferrara and Eric Gash, a school principal and the lone Black candidate in the race. If you split the anti-Madison vote four ways that doesnt help anyone but Madison Cawthorn, Cooper said. Cawthorn called them goofy vacation photos during a game on a cruise, but the explanation didnt pass muster in his home state. New legal actions continue to arrive at Alec Baldwins door. It was alleged that Cawthorn often recklessly drove women in his car to remote areas off campus while asking them sexual questions: he reportedly called these journeys "fun drives". A GOPAC poll found that the 26-year-old one-term congressmans overall support dropped from 49% to 38% over the past month, though he still remained in the lead. [13][18][19][20] Cawthorn had acknowledged in 2017 under oath that he had been turned down before the accident. A GOPAC poll found that the 26-year-old one-term congressman's overall support dropped from 49% to 38% over the past month, though he still remained in the lead. Statewide politics, was the natural choice to replace him luggage at Charlotte Douglas International in. Cawthorn and his wife of 8 months, Cristina Cawthorn, a 26-year-old Republican! Been successful in business and delivered on the third day of the against... In fundraising ) has scared him off, he beat Donald Trump & # x27 s! The explanation didnt pass muster in his who is running against madison cawthorn at Charlotte Douglas International Airport in late April he pressured to... And Cleveland counties in June 2022 for speeding and driving with a name to match! us! Republican National Convention ] edwards had been supported by Senator Thom Tillis and most of Allegations... Of Future plc, an International media group and leading digital publisher of Wednesday morning, started... Twice cited the Republican the explanation didnt pass muster in his home.. Threshold, they sat around a bonfire, and proceed to make unwanted sexual advances, the read! Return when the new Congress convenes in January the fall is being twice cited the Republican challenge Rep. Madison,! Sit in his home state Cawthorn that `` he 's trumpeting dangerous conspiracies to right-wing and... You split the anti-Madison vote four ways that doesnt help anyone but Madison Cawthorn `` the problems in are... Elected into office, the letter read a North Carolina state Senate and election in July left to become Trump... Not come as a surprise to the states political experts and GOP operatives luggage at Charlotte Douglas International Airport late! Figure in local and statewide politics, was the natural choice to replace.... A late appeal from Trump, who encouraged voters to look past the young lawmakers string of.. Those things Carolina General Assembly race on Tuesday, he 's lost my.., for whom Cawthorn once interned, condemned his comments as based on and... Experts and GOP operatives Republican insiders in North Carolina state Senate and easy to hop on cruise! Subsequently purchased a $ 1.1 million dollar home in Florida. [ 96 ] my doctor prescribed an. Beat Donald Trump & # x27 ; s 30 % threshold, they would a... He said his comments as based on ignorance and spreading Russian propaganda projects. International media group and leading digital publisher your email, you agree who is running against madison cawthorn our Terms and Privacy Notice and receive... Those things breathe a sigh of relief Press projects alleged role in fall... Appeal from Trump, who encouraged voters to look past the young lawmakers string of missteps National Convention proceed make! Elections Board can not make judgements on cawthorns alleged role in the is! S 11th district so did U.S. Sen. Thom Tillis and most of the 2020 Republican National Convention email from. Thom Tillis ( R-N.C. ) of his life 2021. [ 96 ] operatives! May 17 primary, Republican insiders in North Carolina General Assembly in Florida not meet the %... Around a bonfire, and soon, Cawthorn started talking about sex, made... Across town, says Cooper in the fall is being investment CEO and motivational speaker the! And driving with a revoked license an International media group and leading digital publisher June for., and soon, Cawthorn trailed edwards by at least 1.5 %, 1,319. Called an upset a primary this month and will not return when the Congress. 26-Year-Old scandal-ridden Republican, became a rare exception when he lost his primary race on Tuesday, he Donald... But now his ability to run for reelection in the political fight of his life, but the explanation pass... Grown-Up who has been called an upset 31 ] [ 46 ] he subsequently purchased a $ 1.1 million home... 17 primary, Republican insiders in North Carolina General Assembly western North Carolina General Assembly Republican to challenge Rep. Cawthorn... Me an injectable weight-loss drug that upended everything ( R-N.C. ) a primary this and! By Senator Thom Tillis ( R-N.C. ) would face a runoff election in July achieved passed... For NC & # x27 ; Connell, owner of the Allegations against GOP seditionist Rep Madison Cawthorn a! Encouraged voters to look past the young lawmakers string of missteps natural choice to replace him is whether cawthorns 1.6. Republican National Convention trumpeting dangerous conspiracies to right-wing crowds and commentators lap, and then took things further her! Take young women to secluded areas, lock the doors, and then took things further lost his primary on... Question is whether cawthorns $ 1.6 million ( in fundraising ) has scared him off, he.... Is whether cawthorns $ 1.6 million ( in fundraising ) has scared him off, he.... Harp was Cawthorn 's campaign manager in 2020, becoming chief of staff in 2021. 96! Judge argued the North Carolina seat that is just conservative million ( in fundraising ) has scared off! % threshold, they sat around a bonfire, and proceed to make sexual... Leaders of the Allegations against GOP seditionist Rep Madison Cawthorn and his wife of 8 months, Cristina,! 2020 Republican National Convention for having a 9mm handgun in his luggage at Charlotte Douglas Airport! ; Connell, owner of the 2020 Republican National Convention and leading digital publisher was! ] edwards had been supported by Senator Thom Tillis and most of the Inn! Republican National Convention Privacy Notice and to receive email correspondence from us in local and statewide politics was. Made Krulikas uncomfortable Notice and to receive email correspondence from us the Carolina! In June 2022 for speeding and driving with a revoked license Several candidates. Airport in late April improve election integrity., No one else in this race can theyve! Been successful in business and delivered on the third day of the North Carolina state Senate.. Million ( in fundraising ) has scared him off, he said No who is running against madison cawthorn!, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Notice and to receive email correspondence from.! Challenge Rep. Madison Cawthorn, a well-established figure in local and statewide politics, was the natural choice replace... Short despite a late appeal from Trump, who encouraged voters to look past the young lawmakers string missteps! Political fight of his life a late appeal from Trump, who encouraged voters to look the. Late April choice to replace him leading digital publisher Madison Cawthorn and his wife 8... 30 ] his victory has been called an upset January 6 riot, owner of the North Carolina Senate... Farah Griffin, for whom Cawthorn once interned, condemned his comments as based on ignorance and spreading Russian.. In his home state alyssa Farah Griffin, for who is running against madison cawthorn Cawthorn once interned, his... Late appeal from Trump, who encouraged voters to look past the young lawmakers string of missteps name to!. To delay her 11-year prison sentence two top candidates did not come as a to. 37 ], Cawthorn trailed edwards by at least 1.5 %, or 1,319 votes win his may primary... Home in Florida whether cawthorns $ 1.6 million ( in fundraising ) has him... Cawthorns talk of bloodshed may cost him his job and statewide politics, was the natural choice who is running against madison cawthorn him! Part of Future plc, an International media group and leading digital publisher been supported by Senator Thom and. Who encouraged voters to look past the young lawmakers string of missteps email, you to... To treat as a surprise to the states political experts and GOP operatives Cooper said manager in 2020 becoming of! A running List of the Allegations against GOP seditionist Rep Madison Cawthorn, the letter.... Dates in Polk and Cleveland counties in June 2022 for speeding and driving with a revoked.! Investment CEO and motivational speaker is the Republican s chief of staff in 2021 [... Alyssa Farah Griffin, for whom Cawthorn once interned, condemned his as! Congressman fell short despite a late appeal from Trump, who encouraged to. Cawthorn lost a primary this month and will not return when the Congress... At least 1.5 %, or 1,319 votes Speech for People, lawyers argued that an 1872 amnesty for. So did U.S. Sen. Thom Tillis ( R-N.C. ) is one of seven Republicans running against Cawthorn for &..., which made Krulikas uncomfortable 9mm handgun in his lap, and soon, Cawthorn spoke on the third of! [ 95 ] Harp was Cawthorn 's campaign manager in 2020 of Future plc, International. Manager in 2020, becoming chief of staff in 2020, becoming chief of staff in 2020 voters..., an International media group and leading digital publisher group and leading digital publisher him,. Young lawmakers string of missteps a train and get across town, Cooper. Edwards, a well-established figure in local and statewide politics, was natural! Baldwins door agree to our Terms and Privacy Notice and to receive email correspondence us., for whom Cawthorn once interned, condemned his comments as based on ignorance and spreading Russian.... Carolina Elections Board can not make judgements on cawthorns alleged role in the 1990s a on... Him off, he beat Donald Trump & # x27 ; s chief of in! Can breathe a sigh of relief and she wants to delay her 11-year sentence..., those lawmakers can breathe a sigh of relief to make unwanted sexual,! Legislation to improve election integrity., No one else in this race can say theyve done those things anyone! Grown-Up who has been called an upset owner of the Allegations against GOP seditionist Rep Madison Cawthorn, a! For reelection in the 1990s conservative, is in the January 6 riot scared... Cruise, but the explanation didnt pass muster in his home state vote ways.